Worth a lookNovember offer: Your project. Your free upgrade. Qualifying full siding or roofing replacement · Up to $2,500 promotional value · Sign during November Year-round: Military (active and veterans) 5% off eligible work · A thank-you for your service. Year-round: First responders 5% off eligible work · For those who serve our communities. Year-round: Past customers 10% off eligible work · Welcome back for your next project. Our commitment: Two-time BBB Torch Award for Ethics recipient Recognized for ethics. Committed to earning your trust.View offers
Siding · Finish and upkeep

LP SmartSide vs. natural cedar: finish and upkeep choices

Our recommendation, the natural-wood exception, and what each finish asks of you.

6 min read

Product sources checked October 21, 2026

The short answer

For a siding replacement, we recommend LP SmartSide over natural cedar. It gives you the wood texture we like, factory-finish choices, and straightforward routine care, with a lower material cost in our experience. We consider cedar for repairs that need to match existing cedar, or when a homeowner is committed to a natural stained-wood appearance. That look is cedar’s strongest reason to choose it—and it comes with a finish-care commitment.

Wood texture or visible natural grain?

Start with the appearance you want to keep. LP SmartSide is engineered wood; its cedar texture is an embossed pattern. Natural cedar has grain and color variation in the wood itself. A painted wood texture and a stain that lets real grain show through are different results.

LP SmartSide also names the board, not every finish sold on it. LP ExpertFinish arrives factory finished. Primed SmartSide still needs its finish paint. Diamond Kote is another factory-finished system built on LP SmartSide, with its own details and care instructions. Our ExpertFinish versus Diamond Kote comparison explains that separate decision.

You cannot use traditional transparent or semi-transparent wood stain on LP SmartSide. A coating that creates a wood-tone appearance does not expose natural cedar grain. Ask for the exact approved finish and a full-size sample rather than choosing from a color name.

Product references: LP finishing FAQ, questions 55–56.

Why we steer replacement projects toward LP

We regularly repair natural cedar with rot and deterioration, split boards, woodpecker damage, and finish problems. Those repairs influence our recommendation. We have not encountered the same range of repair needs with LP in our own work. That is our experience, rather than a controlled comparison of equally aged homes.

LP’s engineered-wood treatment adds to our confidence. It does not establish that every LP installation will outlast every cedar installation. Western Red Cedar has natural decay resistance, but it still needs details that let it dry and care appropriate to its finish. We recommend LP as the more practical replacement choice without assigning either material a guaranteed lifespan.

LP is not woodpecker-proof. LP specifically says its zinc-borate treatment is not effective against woodpeckers or flickers. Our cedar repair experience should not be read as a promise that birds cannot damage LP.

Technical context: Western Red Cedar properties · LP’s woodpecker bulletin · Western Red Cedar finishing and natural-weathering guidance.

Minimal upkeep still includes an annual check

Routine care is one reason we favor prefinished LP. Wash away accumulated dust and dirt gently. For ExpertFinish, LP specifies mild detergent, water, and a soft brush, cloth, or sponge, followed by a low-pressure rinse. Do not use a high-pressure washer.

Once a year, inspect the paint, required caulking, flashing, and gutters. Repair damaged coating and missing or failed sealant where specified; keep drainage gaps open. Keep sprinklers off the siding and soil or mulch below its required clearance.

Factory paint handles the initial finishing, but it does not eliminate eventual repainting. LP calls for repainting before the existing paint fails, using an appropriate high-quality exterior acrylic paint. Plan around coating condition and exposure, rather than treating a finish-warranty term as a repainting schedule. Follow the instructions for the actual finish system on your house.

LP ExpertFinish care and maintenance instructions.

Choose the finish before judging the upkeep

Cedar can be painted, solid-color stained, semi-transparently stained, or allowed to weather. These choices do not have the same appearance or refinishing work. The cedar guidance here concerns Western Red Cedar; identify the species and grade in a proposal.

For visible grain, compare the exact stain

A pigmented semi-transparent stain keeps grain visible while adding color and protection from sunlight. Preserving that appearance requires renewal. Sun exposure, wood texture, preparation, and the chosen coating affect timing; a fixed restaining interval is too broad for every cedar wall.

Painted cedar is another finish system

Paint and solid-color stain cover cedar’s natural color. Cedar’s trade association recommends suitable stain-blocking preparation for opaque finishes. Factory-finished cedar is available too, so factory finishing is not exclusive to LP. If the goal is an opaque color, we still recommend LP rather than paying for natural cedar whose color will be covered.

Natural weathering changes the goal

Letting cedar turn gray avoids maintaining its original color. It does not guarantee even silvering: sheltered and exposed areas can weather differently. Cedar still needs sound moisture details and routine attention. We would not suggest weathering as a shortcut to a uniform, maintenance-free exterior.

Refinishing work also varies. A penetrating stain can often be renewed after proper cleaning, while a peeling paint film may need scraping and other preparation. Get a maintenance plan for the named coating before choosing cedar.

Cedar finish choices and factory finishing · Refinishing and natural-weathering guidance.

Compare complete work—and preserve sound cedar

In our experience, natural cedar costs substantially more to buy than LP SmartSide. That is our material-cost assessment, not a published price for your house. Cedar grade, profile, finish, and quantities change the comparison. Get current installed quotes that include the same removal, wall repairs, flashing, trim, and finishing work.

A primed board price is not comparable with a completed factory-finished package until painting is included. Compare the rest of the project scope as carefully as the siding price. We are not assigning a dollar premium or lifetime savings without matched quotes.

A repair is a different decision from replacing the whole exterior. If sound cedar remains, matching its profile, thickness, and finish can justify using cedar again. A small damaged area does not automatically require a full replacement. Investigate the cause of deterioration so a repair addresses it.

Either material needs correct flashing, drainage, and clearances. A new finish cannot fix a wall detail that keeps trapping water.

Our advice: choose LP unless real cedar is the goal

For replacement siding, LP SmartSide remains our recommendation. We prefer its combination of material value, factory-finish choices, and manageable care. Our confidence comes from our repair experience and the product’s documented design—not a promise of a maintenance-free exterior.

We normally advise against new natural cedar unless a homeowner strongly wants its particular stained appearance. If that is your priority, compare real samples and accept the care plan deliberately. Cedar can be the choice you want even though it is outside our recommendation. Matching an existing cedar repair is the other practical exception.

Put the actual samples, complete installed prices, and finish-care requirements together. If LP gives you the look you want, that is the option we would choose. For a wider comparison, see our siding material buying guide.

Bring the comparison home

Compare the finish and the full project.

Discuss the appearance you want, the work your walls need, and the care you are comfortable taking on.

Discuss your siding